Writing Theoretical Frameworks, Analytical Frameworks And Conceptual Frameworks

theoretical vs conceptual framework

I would extend this definition so that a design may be that of an information resource, tool, activity, environment or educational organisation. In my practice, I have learned and employed a wide range skills including composition of words, graphic design, desktop publishing, video editing and computer programming. I have also tackled the design and making of computer programs, web sites, films, furniture, office spaces, online spaces and rooms to support education.

I regard learning as less likely to succeed when too tightly prescribed and in its nature, a creative activity which benefits from openness in outcome rather than to be restricted to such sequences with too closely focussed learning outcomes. Re-use is rarely possible as the context, conditions and preferences of teachers and learners are so varied. If you’re interested in a qualitative study, be sure to omit arrows and other notations inferring statistical analysis. The only time it would be inappropriate to include a framework in qualitative study is in a grounded theory study, which is not something you’ll do in an applied doctoral study. A tool to help facilitate the understanding of the relationship among concepts or variables in relation to the real-world. Tagged with analytical framework, conceptual framework, theoretical framework. Using a theory-driven conceptual framework in qualitative health research.

Making A Conceptual Framework

The content of conceptual frameworks include reading process, reading aptitude, and the learning-to-read process. Review relevant and updated research on the theme that you decide to work on after scrutiny of the issue at hand. Many people while making researches especially for the first time get caught up in the steps to making a good impression in the theoretical and conceptual framework of the study. Often times, students find it difficult to differentiate between theoretical and conceptual framework. Today, you will be exposed to the meaning of theoretical and conceptual framework and how to write a good theoretical and conceptual framework. You will also see the differences and similarities of theoretical and conceptual framework. A conceptual framework is the researcher’s idea on how the research problem will have to be explored.

As such, locating the theoretical framework proposed in Figure 3.2 within the Hierarchical Influences Model requires contextual adjustments and re-modelling that is useful for this research. There are often multiple theories that inform our understanding of a single phenomenon.

How Do You Start A Theoretical Framework?

Not all aspects of the study are shaped by theory in the theory-informing inductive data analysis study design. Instead, only some aspects of the study design are informed by theory. In this design, the theoretical framework offers a description of which elements of the study are theory informed and how they are informed. The researcher thus has to work to translate insights from theory into specific contributions to elements of the theoretical framework and of the research design. While conceptual frameworks only focus on core ideas identified in their respective studies, theoretical frameworks adhere to an extensive and expansive guideline to inform research. Conceptual frameworks are also presented as a researchers own creation and as a unique inquiry on a given phenomenon and the most appropriate answer. Theoretical frameworks have a deeply ingrained need to be widely accepted after their initial introduction, which is why they are generally well developed .

The question that remains unanswered is how the structure of organisations reflect their allocation of resources, especially as a response to their environment. The practice that has so far been observed has signalled the danger of diminishing media autonomy, especially since the media must cohabit with those who finance it, or those who wield beneficial influence. As such, the power relations as they exists at this level relate closely to the influences these interconnections have exerted on content. The individual https://personal-accounting.org/ level seeks to describe the creators of media content and how individual character traits provide a context within which they appreciate their professional roles. This level recognises the agency of individual journalists or media workers as actors under a larger professional constraint which eventually determines their actions. According to Shoemaker and Reese , the power of media creators includes personal traits and idiosyncrasies that have been exhibited mainly through professional and occupational channels.

This is founded on the theoretical framework, which lies on a much broader scale of resolution. The theoretical framework dwells on time tested theories that embody the findings of numerous investigations on how phenomena occur. Examples of conceptual frameworks include the methods of a chemistry experiment, the definitions a sociologist uses to describe a culture and the types of data an economist considers when evaluating a country’s industry. My design practice has developed with the fundamental assumption that mental models (Craik 1943;Johnson-Laird 1983) are the basis of an individual’s knowledge. Facts and skills could be argued to be the simplest mental models, but I prefer to identify them separately and as building blocks. The iterative view of design is not opposed to a design process base on architectural/engineering specification, where well known and predictive calculations can be made to find the exact dimensions and materials to create a building or bridge.

Instead, the iterative view recognises the unpredictability of the design of education where people, their diversity, complexity and culture are part of the design space, not simply users of an end product. It is not enough to design a computer program which performs to specification, tests correctly and is viewed as satisfactory – in education such software is subject to the richness of human discourse, re-interpretation and creativity. In the process of iterative design, such issues can be explored and the design improved with the evidence gathered to make the most effective theoretical vs conceptual framework educational outcome in a dynamic context. When designing in collaboration, designs require shared meaning in the form of agreed theories amongst the collaborators, in order to evaluate designs and identify room for improvement – my thesis in the form of three analyses is intended to be a basis for this kind of practice. A design science of education should be based on a linguistic framework which offers an intermediate level of systematisation, rising above anecdotes but remaining grounded in reality. The theoretical framework connects the researcher to existing knowledge.

theoretical vs conceptual framework

This allows readers in the field immediate familiarity with the ideas on which a study is based, and a beginning point for critical analysis. I contend that mental models enable explanation, prediction and thus decision-making and action in a much wider sphere than Norman’s focus on the interaction with technology. Nevertheless, it is in the practice of developing better user-interfaces in educational software that my journey as a practitioner started.

Defining The Conceptual Framework

A literature review is a summary or analysis of all the research that you read before doing your own research. It collects key sources on a topic and outlines how those sources and other researchers’ theories align with your study and how you’re using their research to develop your theories.

Similarly, it identifies financial alternatives that are unsuitable for the library. For example, it could answer one research question, which seeks to find out the financial alternatives that would improve the financial stability of Clayton County Library. By doing so, the conceptual framework would also help readers to understand if a financial diversification strategy would make the institution financially stable .

The global nature of news selection leads us to the next theoretical approach in this study, which is the application of postcolonial theory. The terms conceptual and theoretical framework are closely related due to their frequent use in research, but are distinct and refer to two different ideas. Conceptual frameworks are commonly used in new areas of research and are subsequently developed by researchers based on theory.

A conceptual framework is a synthetization of interrelated components and variables which help in solving a real-world problem. It is the final lens used for viewing the deductive resolution of an identified issue . The development of a conceptual framework begins with a deductive assumption that a problem exists, and the application of processes, procedures, functional approach, models, or theory may be used for problem resolution (Zackoff et al., 2019). The application of theory in traditional theoretical research is to understand, explain, and predict phenomena . In applied research the application of theory in problem solving focuses on how theory in conjunction with practice and procedures frames vision, thinking, and action towards problem resolution. The inclusion of theory in a conceptual framework is not focused on validation or devaluation of applied theories.

Researchers use theoretical frameworks to explain the theories they are using within their research and provide context by identifying the assumptions that inform their work. A theoretical framework is often integrated into a literature review section near the beginning of a paper or experiment but can also be included as its own chapter or section. In other words, theory is an all-informing conceptualization that permeates all facets of the study.24 In this approach, the refinement of these existing theories or the development of a new theory may be a major output of the research project. A conceptual framework is finalized before the study and is rarely modified once data collection has started. In the objectivist deductive tradition, a theoretical framework is typically constructed before data collection and is fixed—meaning that a theoretical framework is written before the study beings and remains largely unchanged throughout the research process. After choosing a theory, the researcher can construct the theoretical framework that turns the theory into the object of study.

Guided by a relevant theory, you are given a basis for your hypotheses and choice of research methods. If you’re building a framework, start thinking about how some of those variables, concepts, theories, and facets of existing frameworks come together to shape your problem.

They establish strongly that “sources of content wield important influence” (p. 108) on media content. When sources are routinised, they can be treated at the routine level. They justify the treatment of sources at social institutions level by emphasising the systemic influence they wield. Andreas Schwarz , in search of validation of these ideas, tested the theory of newsworthiness by Johan Galtung and Mari Ruge in Mexico, a non-Western country. Deirdre O’Neill and Tony Harcup maintain that news values can help us understand how some occurrences are marked as “events”, a label which eventually gets them selected as “news”. This theory can also help us explore how some aspects of the selected event get emphasised, while other aspects are downplayed or excluded. To O’Neill and Harcup, in addition to these insights, “news values sometimes blur the distinction between news selection and news treatment” (p. 171).

What Is The Meaning Of Conceptual Framework?

The social institution and social system levels of analysis in Shoemaker and Reese model were collapsed together and embedded in the critical impulse of the postcolonial theory. The review of Vincent Anfara and Norma Mertz demonstrates that the theoretical framework does not have a clear and consistent definition among qualitative researchers.

The Hierarchical Influences Model of Shoemaker and Reese becomes significantly useful for organising the theoretical concepts in this study. This hierarchical model has philosophical underpinnings that ought to be clarified early enough to situate its use in this study. The media as a mirror hypothesis, which argues that media reflects social reality with little distortion, is attractive to journalists because of its power to render content neutral. Shoemaker and Reese make a categorical statement about media content when they assert that media content is “fundamentally a social construction, and as such can never find its analogue in some external benchmark, a mirror or reality” (p. 4). What is crucial for studies on media content is the negotiation of this philosophical premise in an organised manner. Newsworthiness is one of the most utilised theories to explain how and why journalists select news. While some scholars rely heavily on psychology and perceptions of journalists in terms of both what makes news and what their audience’s interests are, others concentrate on the organisational and professional routines rooted within the journalistic practice.

theoretical vs conceptual framework

Here again, development and refinement of theory can come as the end result of the research. We label this the theory-informing inductive data analysis study design. There are 3 main ways that theory is used by subjectivist inductive researchers.19 First, theory can be the product of research. Some subjectivist inductive research—notably researchers working in Glaser and Strauss’s grounded theory tradition20—generates theory from the data. Thus, theory is not used to inform study design but is the major output of the research project and evolves out of a systematic inductive approach to data analysis. This approach represents the most fully inductive approach to subjectivist inductive research. A conceptual framework includes one or more formal theories as well as other concepts and empirical findings from the literature.

Is Literature Review Same As Theoretical Framework?

They point to the reliability of the study from the previous research findings and theories. To add on, these two frameworks can also be presented thru diagrams or illustration. Please complete this reCAPTCHA to demonstrate that it’s you making the requests and not a robot.

theoretical vs conceptual framework

Newsworthiness is not a good predictor of which events get into the newspaper and how they are covered. Newsworthiness is only one of a vast array of factors that influence what becomes the news and how prominently events are covered” (p. 105). For some researchers, the decision as to which theory or theories will inform the final interpretations of the data is a choice that can only be finalized during the data collection and analysis cycles. The researcher holds many theories in mind when designing the study and engaging in data collection. It is not until data analysis processes are underway that the researcher will determine which theory or theories should shape the final study interpretations and conclusions. Consequently, the researcher may have to modify the study design partway through data analysis when he or she realizes that a particular theory is relevant. Instead, it is the result of deep exploration of data that reveals a particular theory to be relevant to the study findings.

When Would You Use A Conceptual Framework?

Thirdly, postcolonialism, also referred to as postcolonial studies, due to its vastness, runs the risk of unwittingly assuming that all colonial experiences were alike and, by so doing, falls prey to the binary scheme of colonial and postcolonial. The object-based approach to news selection argues that events have some specific characteristics that are attractive to journalists; the more of these characteristics an event seems to possess, the more likely it is that journalists will select it. The argument that the nature of an event itself is the biggest predictor of newsworthiness to journalists ignores the subject-object relationship .

What Is The Difference Between Conceptual Review And Conceptual Framework?

A theoretical framework, the way I define it, is comprised of the different theories and theoretical constructs that help explain a phenomenon. A theoretical framework sets out the various expectations that a theory posits and how they would apply to a specific case under analysis, and how one would use theory to explain a particular phenomenon. Dr. Cyrus Samii offers an explanation of what a good theoretical framework does for students. The superimposition of the postcolonial theory on the theories of newsworthiness and intermedia agenda-setting is categorical in nature. This does not mean that the postcolonial theory is more useful than the two other theories; it only signifies the overarching critical impulse of it. The positioning of these theories in the model only represents the way the study conceives of their analytical application. What is new about this approach is that the weaknesses of the theory of newsworthiness, for example, to explicate meso- and macro-level influences on news selection decisions are minimised because other theories within the integrated framework can be used.

Throughout first week, I notice the few customers they have are leaving unsatisfied. I need to figure out why and turn the establishment into a thriving restaurant. I get permission from the owner to do a study to figure out exactly what we need to do to raise levels of customer satisfaction. Since I have a specific problem and want to make sure my research produces valid results, I go to the literature to find out what others are finding about customer satisfaction in the food service industry.

One way to do this is to not rely exclusively on the theories developed within your particular discipline, but to think about how an issue might be informed by theories developed in other disciplines. Building theoretical frameworks based on the postulates and hypotheses developed in other disciplinary contexts can be both enlightening and an effective way to be more engaged in the research topic. A theoretical framework consists of concepts and, together with their definitions and reference to relevant scholarly literature, existing theory that is used for your particular study. The theoretical framework must demonstrate an understanding of theories and concepts that are relevant to the topic of your research paper and that relate to the broader areas of knowledge being considered. A lot of people have asked me if the theoretical framework is their literature review.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *